In the 1970 cohort, children of immigrants showed significant gaps at ages 5 and 10 in reading and maths assessments. However, no gaps were found in the 2000-01 cohort at ages 11 and 14.
The research examines the cognitive development of children born in the UK to two immigrant parents by modelling assessment scores in reading and maths. The author compares the findings from assessments undertaken during the 1970 British Cohort Study (BCS70) with those which formed part of the more recent Millennium Cohort Study (MCS) to examine whether children of immigrants achieve along systematically different trajectories when compared to children of non-immigrants and whether children of immigrants today are performing better academically than their counterparts 30 years ago.
The 1970 British Cohort Study (BCS70) follows the lives of 17,198 people born in England, Scotland and Wales in a single week of 1970.
The Millennium Cohort Study (MCS) is following the lives of 19,517 children born across England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland in 2000-01.
In the BCS70, reading was assessed at ages 5 and 10 using the Schonell Reading model and scores were standardized to give them a mean of 50 and a standard deviation of 10; for the MCS cohort, reading (or verbal skills) was assessed at ages 3, 5, 7, 11 and 14 using age-appropriate British Ability Scales models. These scores also underwent transformation to give them a mean of 50 and a standard deviation of 10.
In the BCS70, maths skills were assessed at ages 5 and 10 using the Copying Designs (age 5) and Friendly Maths (age 10) models; for the MCS cohort, maths (or quantitative) skills were assessed at ages 3, 5, 7 and 11, again using age-appropriate models. As with reading assessment scores, maths scores were standardized to give them a mean of 50 and a standard deviation of 10.
In the BCS70 cohort, children of immigrants show significant gaps at ages 5 and 10 in both reading and maths scores. Even after controlling for gender, socioeconomic status, residential location, birth order and home language environment, children of Caribbean immigrants appear to perform worse in both assessments.
On the other hand, no gaps remain in age-11 and age-14 assessments for the MCS cohort. Indeed in the final model, all children of immigrants follow positive trajectories and Indian children of immigrants even out-perform their peers.
Detailed cross-cohort analysis can allow us to examine how cognitive achievement has changed amongst children of immigrants at similar developmental time points in the last 30 years. The cognitive assessment scores of children born to immigrants in 1970 (relative to their peers) are compared to those of immigrant children born in 2000-01 (again, relative to their peers) and this can provide important insights as to the relative attainment of minorities in these two birth cohorts. Using longitudinal data from each of the cohort studies also allows the author to plot development trajectories over time using consecutive waves of assessment data to give a clearer understanding of when any differences emerge or disappear.
Nonetheless, there are some key challenges involved in adopting this approach. In particular, the comparability between measures used in the two cohort studies will necessarily be approximate as they employ different instruments and are not always administered at the same age. Indeed, analysis of the older cohort is restricted to assessments at two time points, whereas for the young cohort data are available relating to four or five assessment waves.
The author focuses more attention on the more recent cohort, for which a much greater amount of information is available and can undertake more complex multilevel modelling to assess the relative importance of several individual- and family-level characteristics for this cohort of young people. However, this analysis is limited to the MCS cohort and therefore no comparison with the older BCS70 cohort.
The issue of minority ethnic children’s educational underachievement was first highlighted by the Swann Report (1985) and, since then, has received much academic and policy attention. The findings of this study show positive trends in the educational development of immigrant children in the present day, compared to the cohort of 30 years ago. However, the author cautions against undue optimism and highlights that continued policy initiatives promoting ethnic minorities’ achievement are required to ensure that these trends do not experience any back-sliding. A more fine-grained examination of individual ethnic groups’ educational experiences and attainment would also allow for more targeted policies towards supporting the more vulnerable groups.
Hoffmann, N. I. (2018). Cognitive achievement of children of immigrants: Evidence from the Millennium Cohort Study and the 1970 British Cohort Study. British Educational Research Journal, 44(6), 1005-1028.